You can not compare between does two because Mei is a pitcher and Miyuki is a catcher.

I agree. You cannot really compare them because their positions are different. However, both are talented and skilled (even prodigies) in their own respective positions (Mei as pitcher and Miyuiki as catcher).

I totally agree with you two. it's like comparing an apple to an orange. I just came across a fb fan page. But in batter/pitcher match-up who do you think will dominate?

In a batting match-up, hmm...I think Mei is a little better but according to their stats, Miyuki wins by a small margin.